Skip to main content

Positions for Women: The Fallacy of Reserving Gender Quotas

Image Credit: tasteofhome.com 















The new Kenyan Constitution established a gender equity clause. For public positions, members of any gender may not hold more than two third the positions. Based on it, for the first time, Kenyans will be voting for women representatives to the senate in the coming election.

Elsewhere, there has been a growing call for the inclusion of women in various leadership positions, and general inclusion of women in many other places. In Africa, the girl-child NGO industry is quite large, and may eclipse the budget of a number of African countries.

In Norway, about 100 of 500 companies are said to have delisted as a reaction to a rule that mandated women in boards. (More about that here http://www.womenonboards.org.au/pubs/articles/norway_bigpicture.htm)

Meanwhile, elsewhere, Yahoo became another big tech company to have a Woman CEO. When 30 year old Marissa Mayer joined Yahoo as the companies CEO, she was  in her third trimester of pregnancy. After her delivery, she was back to her desk in two weeks. She is also said to have worked through her short maternity leave. You will agree that this lady here gives ammunition to those fighting for gender empowerment, with the right, and takes it away with left.
Mayer is also on the board of five other firms.

She joins Ginni Rometty, IBM’s CEO. Now, IBM sponsors an annual prestigious golf tournament at Augusta National. It is customary for the IBM CEO to be invited to join the membership ranks of Augusta National.  However, for Rometty, she was not invited to join the prestigious membership ranks at Augusta National. See, they are not about to admit their first female member, as yet.

From the earlier link on women on Norwegian boards, the article states that having reached their target at the top, it was now time to embark on lower levels of management.

A while ago, a friend (on Twitter) shared their experience on a visit to a wine producing region in South Africa, which are still almost exclusively white. The region had been pressured to maintain a white-black racial balance. Firms in the region were thus employing black South Africans as a result. My friend chatted one of the blacks, who admitted that he really didn’t do much, and that he enjoyed the high flying life in the town, with horses and all. Well, he was assured of his job, as the employer couldn’t fire him, in a bid to maintain racial balance.

A focus on maintaining balance, how many numbers of a certain people, might not go down well with an organisation that is more focused on performance. Again, the insistence on the balance starting from the top and trickling downwards also introduces a challenge. Performing and effective leaders are supposed to be the cream of the crop. If there’s no emphasis to increase the number of women up the ranks, it thus becomes harder to pick women.

Another problem in the gender balance issue comes from societal biases towards women. Despite the first programmer being a woman, the number of women in tech is not something one can write home about. The numbers remain low, despite an equal opportunity policy and even policies that place emphasis on women.

See, women are brought up and geared towards certain biases. Barbie toys are for girls, cars and plane replicas are for boys. In rural areas, home keeping tasks are allocated to girls while menial tasks are allocated to the boys.

Looking at education, there is a bias towards certain subjects for boys and girls. In 2010, 158,344 girls sat for English Kenya Certificate of Secondary Education(KCSE) against 196,607 boys.

155,725 girls sat for Chemistry against 191,653 boys. 1

48,729 girls sat for Biology against 166,334 boys.

A paltry 29,964 girls sat for Chemistry against 79,108 boys.

In the Social Sciences 97,546 girls sat for History against 127,980 boys.

44,471 sat for Geography against 67,175 boys.

128,762 girls sat for Christian Religious Education against 111,458 boys.

0 girls sat for Woodwork against 374 boys.

1 girl sat for Metalwork against 219 boys.

12 girls sat for Building and Construction against 211 boys.

3 girls sat for Power Mechanics against 156 boys.

No girl dared be caught dead sitting for the Electricity  exam, which 161 boys sat for.

A bias is clearly in the making, for what careers are “right” for girls. The other reason might be that some subjects are deemed “too difficult” for girls to study. In addition, you may find that girls schools are not equipped to teach some subject, either to low interest, or them being deemed not that necessary for girls.

Elsewhere, a friend who does sales for a publisher was remarking that the job is not suitable for ladies under the age of 30. At his workplace, he said that most ladies who joined the sales department ended up asking to be reassigned to other desk jobs in the office. After months in the sales department, the ladies did have a number of “working lunches”, but little in terms of sales to show compared to the males.

Rather than allocate slots to be filled up by a specific gender, it would be better if there was a focus on providing an equal playground to both genders. Girls, meanwhile will need to be encouraged more to try out the opportunities that are reserved for the boys, if they are willing to.

The biggest hindrance to women in society is bias, rather than slots allocated to them. Again, it is worth remembering that men and women generally see things different, and prefer them differently, but this should not stop individuals who prefer them differently.

Should we hire ladies because they are good at what they do, or because we need ladies to fill a few slots.

2010 KCSE Statistics: http://www.scribd.com/doc/49933701/KCSE-statistics

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Beers in Kenya: A sober opinion

Note: This is a dated post and has since been mostly passed by events. SAB Miller beers including Castle and Peroni are no longer widely available in Kenya after their exist. Sirville Brewery was bought out by Brew Bistro before being permanently shut in a tax dispute. Kenya is a land of milk, honey, beaches and taxes. I have penned, or is typed, a newer post here .  Peroni - One of the best beers in Kenya. Did a taste of canned and bottled Italian, and bottled Tanzanian I like the tangy flavour and body in Tanzanian Peroni. The can is close. Heineken drinkers will like the Italian one.  I have had a short beer swigging stint in my life. It has however been long enough for me to share my opinion of Kenyan beer. Interestingly, over the course of sharing such opinions with other drunkards connoisseurs,  I have found that we all have different views as to what beer is the best, which one makes you too drunk, or which one gives one free, extra hangover for every hangover you get

When none of your business becomes your business

Martha Karua, one of our most hyped politicians, was in the news again. This time round, it appears her god-like status is now fading as quickly as it came up. Some of her constituents were demonstrating against her; odd it was that they were motor-cycle taxi men, not demonstrating against her motor cycle policies, but against her so called support for the mungiki. It is odd, since the activities of the mungiki do not affect cyclists alone, but the constituency as a whole. This had reeked a strong oduor of hired demonstrators, as she claims. As for the demonstrators and the planners, they appeared to have made a judgemental error when they claimed that their MP was supporting the mungiki. Martha Karua, been a sensible person and a lawyer, has been against the stance that the government is taking against the mungiki, by allowing other so called vigilante groups to hunt for mungiki and kill them. Been against this method, does not mean that you support the mungiki;the two aren'

Twitter? What the hell?

Twitter has been in the news on several occasions in the recent past. It all began with a few celebrities using twitter, then it caught on to CNN and Ashton Kutcher going head to head for who gets a million followers first. Ashton Kutcher beat CNN in what was the first demise of CNN on Twitter. This event was closely by Oprah's grand entry into twitter. It was at this point that many people actually joined twitter. Oprah happened to be a major occasion on twitter, with many geeks anticipating that twitter would be overwhelmed by the interest brought on it by Oprah and her millions (if they haven't hit a billion) of fans worldwide. In fact, we gave a Before Oprah and After Oprah Twitter ages. Twitter has continued growing, with it been claimed to be the fastest growing social network in the world, with a growth rate of about 1300% per month. Ironically , a Harvard research says that only 10% of twitter users contribute to 90 % of the content on twitter; the content is known as

Nairobi's Top 4 Texas Brisket Places Reviewed and Ranked

Brisket on a bed of roast vegetables with barbecue sauce at Texas Brisket, Kikuyu  This review has been updated after a number of you suggested I try the brisket at County2County.  What's the best place to have Brisket in Nairobi? What's even brisket?  Brisket is one of the toughest cuts in a cow, from around the belly. It is so tough that it has to be smoked for about 16 hours to tenderise. But that there, is the catch.  12 to 16 hours later, it is the most flavourful and softest cut you will ever have. So full of flavour and so soft you can pick it apart with your fingers.  However, due to the long cooking time involved, only a few places offer brisket in Nairobi.  The best so far is Texas Brisket which is located within Kikuyu Railway station.  They do the meat for a proper 16 hours, and will usually have a fatty or non-fatty portion. The fatty portions are more tasty. A 500 gram serving goes for KSh. 900 and a 1 KG order comes with a serving of free fries. Their brisket has

Kenyan products: The art of punishing your consumer

This post was written in 2011. Facts may have and indeed have changed - but the conclusion has not.  Dormans instant coffee tastes better than Sasini instant coffee. Ramtons electronics are manufactured for Kenya's Hypermart Limited, yet maintain a high product quality Peanut butter used to taste so good, but you could not afford it on the pocket money that you got back in school. A few years later, you have your first real job and your first "disposable" income. You buy your first real tub of peanut butter, probably the first in your life. You feel proud that Dominion peanut butter is manufactured in Ruiru, a town that you visited in your campus days to withdraw your pocket money, it was the nearest bank ATM to your campus.  This was before Equity bank became a mainstream bank and decided to open an ATM in your campus, and before M-Pesa meant that you